Life After Infidelity: Can Trust Be Rebuilt?

Are the feelings after infidelity normal, and can trust be rebuilt? Read about the psychological effects of being cheated on and ways of recovering.

At the moment you learn your partner has cheated on you, you may feel as if your life has suddenly split in two: before and after. Everything you thought you knew about the person you trusted, about your relationship, even about your own perception begins to be questioned. The shock, anger, shame and deep hurt felt after infidelity are among the most shattering emotional experiences many people go through. In this article we look at why being cheated on feels so devastating, how natural the feelings in this process are, how to decide between staying in the relationship and ending it, and whether trust can be rebuilt.

Why Does Infidelity Cause Such a Deep Wound?

Infidelity is not just the breaking of a promise of faithfulness. This experience shakes a person's sense of trust in the relationship, the way they see themselves and their memories of the past all at once. Questions such as "Was everything they told me a lie?", "What did I fail to see?" and "Wasn't I good enough?" begin to occupy the mind.

A close relationship is thought of as one of the places where a person feels safest. Infidelity can turn this safe space into a dangerous one. That is why many specialists regard infidelity as a relationship trauma. This does not mean that every experience of being cheated on leads to post-traumatic stress disorder; but it does show that the reactions experienced can resemble those seen after a traumatic event.

The form infidelity takes can also change its impact. A one-off incident, a long-term secret affair, emotional intimacy or relationships formed in online settings can be experienced in different ways. But whatever form it takes, what is fundamentally experienced is the breaking of trust.

What Feelings Are Experienced After Infidelity?

The feelings experienced in this period are often intense, complex and contradictory. In the same day you may feel both anger and longing for your partner, and while wanting to end the relationship, in the next hour you may be afraid of losing them.

Emotional Reactions

• Shock and denial: Being unable to believe the truth that has been learnt, a feeling of "This can't be happening."
• Intense anger: Anger directed at the partner, at the third person and sometimes at yourself.
• Deep sadness and loss: A sense of losing the former state of the relationship and the imagined future.
• Shame and worthlessness: Feeling inadequate, deceived or humiliated.
• Anxiety and insecurity: Suspecting your partner's every move, being constantly on guard.
• Guilt: Holding yourself responsible for what happened, the question "Where did I go wrong?"

Thought and Behavioural Reactions

• Constantly thinking about and replaying the details of what happened
• The urge to check your partner's phone, social media or movements
• Sleep problems, changes in appetite, difficulty concentrating
• Feelings that suddenly intensify in particular places, songs or dates
• Wanting to know everything on the one hand, and on the other being hurt even more by what you hear

Imagine that in a ten-year marriage, one spouse finds out that their partner has been messaging someone else for a long time. In the first days they can barely sleep, can't concentrate on their work, and rethink every past business trip and every late-night message. On the one hand they want to know everything, and on the other every new detail they learn deepens their pain. These reactions are not a sign of weakness; they are understandable responses to a major shock.

The intense feelings you experience after being cheated on do not show that you are exaggerating; they show that something very precious to you has been damaged.

Why Do People Cheat?

This is one of the questions the person who has been cheated on most wants answered. Infidelity does not have a single cause, and the existence of a reason does not remove responsibility for the behaviour. Even so, understanding the dynamics behind infidelity can help some couples make sense of the process.

• Emotional disconnection in the relationship: In relationships where deep conversations, attention and closeness have declined for a long time, some people may look elsewhere for what is missing.
• Unresolved conflicts: Accumulated resentments, unspoken anger and unmet needs.
• Individual reasons: Low self-esteem, a need for validation, thrill-seeking, avoidance of intimacy or impulsivity.
• Life transitions: Periods such as having a child, losing a job, midlife or losing a loved one can cause a person to question their identity and their relationship.
• Problems in the sexual relationship: Unspoken sexual dissatisfaction or incompatibility.
• Opportunity and boundaries: The workplace, social media and online platforms can create situations in which boundaries become blurred.

The person who cheated may also go through intense feelings such as guilt, shame, fear of loss and confusion. Sometimes these feelings are expressed outwardly as defensiveness or a wish to close the subject. Understanding these reactions matters not in order to downplay the impact of what happened, but to see that the healing process can be hard for both sides.

It is important to stress this here: having problems in the relationship does not mean that the person who was cheated on "deserved" it. The problems could have been addressed in other ways; cheating is a choice, and responsibility belongs to the one who makes that choice.

After Infidelity, Should You Stay or End the Relationship?

This is one of the hardest decisions the person who was cheated on has to make, and there is no universally right answer. While some couples succeed in rebuilding their relationship after this crisis, for others separation may be a healthier option.

During the decision process you can ask yourself the following questions:

• Is my partner taking responsibility for what happened, or are they blaming me or circumstances?
• Has the affair really ended?
• Is my partner willing to answer my questions honestly?
• Before I was cheated on, was our relationship generally good for me?
• Is my reason for wanting to stay in the relationship love, or fear of being alone, financial worries or social pressure?

In Turkey, particularly among married couples, sayings such as "Put up with it for the children", "Don't let the family fall apart", "Men do this sort of thing" or "What will the neighbours say" can influence the decision. These sayings can make it harder for a person to hear their own needs. The involvement of extended family members can sometimes be supportive and sometimes a factor that complicates decision-making even further.

Instead of making big decisions in the first weeks, it can be helpful, if possible, to wait for the feelings to settle a little. If there is violence, threats or situations that endanger your safety, then the priority is always your safety and that of your children, if you have any; in emergencies call 112 (Turkey's emergency services).

If you decide to end the relationship, you can find suggestions for coping with the feelings in this process in our article on the pain of separation.

How Is Trust Rebuilt After Infidelity?

Rebuilding trust is possible, but it requires time, effort and the willingness of both sides. This process does not move in a straight line; after good days, a triggering event can bring difficult feelings to the surface again.

Responsibilities of the Partner Who Cheated

• Ending the affair clearly
• Taking responsibility for what happened without becoming defensive
• Answering the partner's questions patiently and honestly
• Being willing to be transparent
• Not belittling the partner's feelings and not trying to speed up the process by saying "It's in the past now"
• Being open to understanding, within themselves, why they cheated and to working on it

Self-Care for the Partner Who Was Cheated On

• Making room for your feelings instead of suppressing them
• Not neglecting basic needs such as sleep, nutrition and movement
• Sharing what you have been through with one or two people you trust, while bearing in mind that sharing with everyone may cause regret later
• Accepting your need to ask questions about the details, but also recognising that not every detail serves healing
• Approaching yourself with compassion instead of blaming yourself

How Does Trust Return Step by Step?

Trust is rebuilt not through grand promises but through repeated small and consistent behaviours. Coming home at the time you said, giving information without being asked, keeping promises and not avoiding difficult questions can, over time, help the partner who was cheated on feel safe again. In this process it is also important for the partner who was cheated on to notice when and how their sense of trust increases. Sometimes noticing that the need to check has lessened, or sometimes that you feel at ease again next to your partner, are valuable signs that healing is taking place. This progress is usually experienced not in a straight line but with ups and downs.

What the Couple Can Do Together

• Talking about the problems in the relationship not as a justification for infidelity but as part of the rebuilding process
• Making space to talk at set times in a calm setting
• Agreeing on new relationship rules and boundaries
• Noticing and appreciating small but consistent steps of trust

Coping With Triggers

During healing, a particular song, a restaurant, a notification on your partner's phone or a meeting that runs late can suddenly bring intense feelings back to life. These moments do not mean healing has gone back to the start. It can help to notice the triggers, share them with your partner in a calm moment and work out together what you need in such moments. For example, some couples agree that after the triggered partner says "I'm struggling right now", the other stays by their side without becoming defensive. Over time, such experiences can turn into small but meaningful steps that contribute to rebuilding trust.

Children and Family Circle

How the crisis will affect the children is also an important source of worry for couples with children. Children can sense the tension at home even if they don't know the details. Not sharing adult matters with children, not forcing them to take sides and keeping their daily routines as far as possible support children's sense of security in this period. Not rushing when deciding how much to share with the extended family and circle of friends may leave you room for the decisions you will make about the relationship later.

The first months of this process are often the hardest. It is important to be patient and to accept that healing will take time.

When Should You Seek Professional Support?

In this process it can be helpful to get support from a specialist in the following situations:

• If intense feelings still markedly affect your daily life despite weeks passing
• If sleep, appetite and concentration problems continue
• If you are reliving what happened in your mind non-stop and feel constantly on guard
• If thoughts of worthlessness and hopelessness about yourself have intensified
• If you cannot decide whether to continue or end the relationship and feel stuck
• If your conversations as a couple constantly end in arguments
• If you are having thoughts of harming yourself (in emergencies call 112 (Turkey's emergency services))

How Is the Process After Infidelity Approached in Therapy?

Therapy after infidelity can be carried out individually or as a couple, according to the needs of the person and the couple.

In individual therapy, we work with the shock, anger and feelings of loss experienced by the person who was cheated on. With a cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) approach, thoughts such as "I'm not good enough" and "I can never trust anyone again" are noticed and more balanced perspectives are developed. Coping skills are gained for reactions such as images that replay in the mind, triggers and sleep problems. The person is supported in making their decision about the relationship in line with their own values and needs.

In couples therapy, the process usually moves through several stages. In the first stage, calming the crisis, expressing feelings in a safe setting and the partner who cheated taking responsibility are in the foreground. Next, the relationship context in which the infidelity took place is explored; the aim here is not to apportion blame but to see at which points the relationship became fragile. In the final stage, the couple works together on a new relationship agreement, a way of communicating and intimacy. You can find this process in detail on our couples therapy page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does trust come back completely after infidelity?

It is more realistic to speak of building a new and different relationship of trust than of trust returning to its former state. Where both sides are willing and take consistent steps, many couples can feel safe again over time.

Do I have to forgive infidelity?

No. Forgiving is not an obligation but a decision a person makes at their own pace and on their own terms. Forgiving also does not mean approving of what happened or continuing the relationship.

Does learning the details of the infidelity help healing?

Knowing the answers to some questions can help you make sense of what happened. However, learning every detail can deepen the pain by increasing the images that replay in the mind. It can be helpful to assess together with a specialist which information will really do you good.

What can I do if the partner who cheated doesn't want to come to therapy?

Even if your partner does not want to take part in couples therapy, you can get support individually. An individual process can help you make sense of what you have been through and make the right decision for you; taking this step is always possible.

• #infidelity
• #unfaithfulness
• #trust
• #marriage problems

Yazar

Eda Erkan Alapala

Klinik Psikolog. İstanbul Kent Üniversitesi Klinik Psikoloji Tezli Yüksek Lisans mezunu; bilişsel davranışçı terapi, çocuk merkezli oyun terapisi ve çocuk-ergen psikoterapisi alanlarında eğitimlerini tamamlamıştır.

Eğitimler