For couples with father-in-law problems: the roots of authoritarian behaviour, a spouse who can't say no to his father and how to keep a respectful distance.
At dinner one evening, your father-in-law puts down his fork and makes a short announcement: "The top floor of our building has become free. You're moving in there at the end of the month; you won't need to pay rent." Nobody asks anything, nobody objects. Your spouse lowers his head, your mother-in-law starts clearing the table with a satisfied look. And you realise that a decision about your own life has been made without anyone consulting you. In Turkey, father-in-law problems often remain in the shadow of tensions with the mother-in-law; but especially in families where the culture of the head of the household is strong, a father-in-law's authority can determine a couple's decisions, their budget, even the way they raise their children. In this article we look at how tension with an authoritarian father-in-law arises, the dilemma of a spouse who cannot stand up to his father, and how a healthy distance can be established without breaking the relationship.
What Kind of Problem Are Father-in-Law Problems?
Problems with a father-in-law are generally of a different tone from those with a mother-in-law. A mother-in-law's interference is often seen in the details of daily life: food, the running of the home, childcare. A father-in-law's interference, by contrast, shows itself more in major decisions and through authority.
An authoritarian father-in-law's behaviour usually appears in these forms:
- The father who decides: having the final word on where the couple will live, what job they will do, which car they will buy, even what name they will give their children.
- The father who criticises: constantly questioning his son's or son-in-law's decisions about work, money and running the home, and belittling him in front of others.
- The father who punishes in silence: cutting off conversation when challenged, sulking, not greeting people at religious festivals, creating an indirect threat by mentioning inheritance or support.
- Financial control: having a say in the couple's life through a house, a car, a workplace or a share in the family business.
- Patriarchal expectations: rules he expects the daughter-in-law to follow, from serving tea to how she dresses, whether she works and what time she comes home.
Each of these behaviours may seem small on its own. But taken together, they seriously erode the couple's sense of running their own life.
What Lies Behind an Authoritarian Father-in-Law's Behaviour?
An authoritarian attitude is very often fed not by a person's ill will but by the family and social model in which he grew up.
Generation and role: Many fathers who are now in their sixties and seventies grew up at a time when the father was the unquestioned authority in the home. For them, steering their children's lives is not interference but a natural part of the duty of fatherhood. In their eyes, the sentence "I'm your father, I know best" expresses not a right but a responsibility.
Retirement and loss of role: When a man who made decisions, managed others and was listened to at work retires, this need for authority may turn towards the family. Getting more involved in his children's lives can be a way of still feeling useful and important.
Anxiety: Beneath authoritarian behaviour there is very often anxiety. Concerns such as economic uncertainty, worries about his children's future or protecting family property can surface as tight control.
His own father: Many authoritarian fathers grew up with an even harsher father in their own childhood. They continue what they saw from their own father, because they have never known another model of fatherhood.
Difficulty expressing emotion: Men who cannot directly voice their love and anxiety may express them through control, advice and financial support. The "order" to move in is sometimes really the only way he knows of saying "I want to be close to you".
Understanding these reasons does not mean you have to accept your father-in-law's behaviour. But seeing the authority directed at you not as a personal attack but as the product of a generation and a role makes it easier to choose your reactions more calmly.
How Do Father-in-Law Problems Affect the Couple?
A father-in-law's authority often settles quietly into the couple's relationship.
Decisions are postponed or handed over. Before deciding anything, the couple asks, "What will Dad say?" Over time, the options the father would approve of come to the fore instead of the couple's own preferences.
The spouse becomes childlike. A man in his father's presence can suddenly turn into a child whose voice drops and who cannot object. This change can make the husband look weak or unprotective in his wife's eyes, and creates resentment.
The daughter-in-law is left alone. A daughter-in-law who does not want to comply with her father-in-law's patriarchal expectations becomes a one-woman opposition within the family when she gets support from neither her husband nor her mother-in-law.
Financial dependence limits freedom. Living in the father-in-law's house, working in his business or receiving regular support from him reduces the couple's power to object. The thought "He gave us a home; what can we say?" can make setting boundaries almost impossible. In couples who work in the father-in-law's family business, the boundaries between work and family become even more blurred; the article on conflict in family businesses may also offer guidance on this.
Children are affected. When a grandfather who takes a harsh approach to discipline with his grandchildren clashes with the rules the parents have set, the child is caught between two separate authorities.
The bride's father and the son-in-law
Father-in-law problems are not something only daughters-in-law experience. There are also men who struggle with their wife's father, and this relationship has a language of its own. The "bride's father" is culturally a protective figure; he may watch his son-in-law for a long time as if he were sitting an exam. Every comment about the son-in-law's job, income or way of making decisions can turn into a silent test of strength between the two men. The son-in-law fears that if he stands up to his father-in-law he will seem disrespectful, and if he stays silent he will seem weak in his wife's eyes. In this dilemma the woman, too, is caught between her father and her husband. The love and loyalty she feels for her father can make it harder for her to see her husband's hurt. The principle here is the same: when each partner takes on talking to their own father and the couple defends its decisions together, the tension between the two men does not settle at the centre of the marriage.
The Spouse Who Can't Say "No" to His Father
At the centre of father-in-law problems there is very often a man or woman squeezed between their father and their spouse. If your spouse cannot stand up to his father, several feelings are usually intertwined beneath this:
- Fear: someone who faced his father's anger as a child may continue to dread that same anger as an adult.
- Respect and loyalty: the belief that "standing up to my father is bad manners" carries not only a personal but a cultural weight.
- A sense of debt: the sacrifices his father made for him can make objecting feel like ingratitude.
- Seeking approval: some adults are still waiting for their father to say "Well done" just once.
When you expect your spouse to stand firm against his father, it is important to see these feelings. A criticism such as "Why can't you say anything to your father?" corners him even further. "I can see how hard it is for you to talk to your father; how can we do this together?" makes him feel you are supporting him. You can also read the article on father–son conflict about the unspoken tensions between fathers and sons.
Suggestions for a Healthy Distance from an Authoritarian Father-in-Law
Changing an authoritarian father-in-law is very often not possible. But strengthening your own space as a couple is.
Announce decisions rather than opening them up for debate
A common mistake with authoritarian parents is submitting every decision for their approval. Instead, you can make your decision as a couple and announce it in respectful language: "Dad, we've thought about this for a long time and we've decided to stay in our own home. Thank you very much for the offer." This sentence shows respect for his opinion while making it clear that the decision belongs to you.
Take small steps towards financial independence
Financial dependence is one of the biggest obstacles to setting boundaries. Even if full independence is not possible straight away, small savings, a separate account or reducing the areas in which you receive support strengthen the couple's hand over time. Because of the cost of living these steps may progress slowly; what matters is that the direction is clear and that the couple owns this goal together. A target date or a concrete savings plan gives far more strength than the vagueness of "One day we'll stand on our own two feet".
Keep the rituals of respect
For an authoritarian father-in-law, signs of respect are very important. Rituals such as kissing his hand at religious festivals, calling on important days and asking his opinion show that, while you are setting boundaries, the relationship has not been severed. Respect and boundaries are not alternatives to each other.
Limit the areas of conflict
On topics such as politics, religion or work that turn into an argument every time, rather than competing over opinions at the table you can choose to change the subject gently. Saying "We see this differently, Dad; let's leave it so we can enjoy today" makes room without fighting the authority.
Defend the rules about the grandchildren together
Agree on a shared stance as a couple about how your children are to be treated, and protect that stance together in your father-in-law's presence. Behaviour towards a child such as shouting, humiliation or physical punishment should not be accepted, even when it comes from a family elder.
Leave the room when tempers flare
When your father-in-law gets angry, rather than answering back or keeping quiet and accepting everything, you can calmly leave the situation: "This isn't a good time to discuss this; let's continue later." This allows you both to protect yourself and to stop the conversation escalating.
Let's say a retired father-in-law criticised his son's decision to change jobs at every family meal and eventually got up from the table and left. The couple explained the decision to him once, calmly and clearly, and at subsequent meals, when the subject came up, politely moved on to another topic. A few months later the father-in-law no longer raised it; he never said he accepted it, but he stopped objecting.
The strongest stance against authority is not shouting, but a calm and consistent "no".
When Should You Seek Professional Support?
If the tension with an authoritarian father-in-law has reached the following levels, getting support from a specialist may be helpful:
- As a couple you cannot make any decision without your father-in-law's approval
- Your spouse can never stand up for your rights in front of his father, and this hurts you deeply
- You experience intense anxiety, stomach aches or sleeplessness before family gatherings
- Your father-in-law's anger frightens you or your children
- There are insults, threats, economic abuse or physical violence (in this case your safety comes before everything else; support is available from ALO 183, Turkey's social support hotline, and in an emergency call 112, the emergency services)
These signs do not on their own mean a diagnosis; but they do show that the burden should not be carried alone.
How Are Father-in-Law Problems Addressed in Therapy?
In couples therapy, the work focuses on the couple's boundaries with the extended family and their capacity to make decisions on their own. The therapist helps the partners decide together how they can support each other in their relationship with the father-in-law, and on which issues they can be flexible and on which they can stand firm.
Individual work can also be valuable for the spouse who cannot object to their father. Within Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, thoughts such as "If I go against my father, I'll be a bad child" or "I couldn't bear it if my father got angry with me" are examined, and the person learns step by step to find their own voice while maintaining respect. A schema therapy perspective helps explain how childhood patterns such as subjugation and approval-seeking are reflected in adult family relationships.
Personal space is also important for the daughter-in-law or son-in-law struggling with an authoritarian father-in-law. Someone who is constantly criticised and whose decisions are disregarded may, over time, find it hard to trust their own judgement. In therapy, this person's anger, sense of helplessness and the guilt they feel when setting boundaries are addressed; by rehearsing difficult conversations in session, they are supported in staying calmer and more self-assured in real encounters.
Frequently Asked Questions
We live in a house my father-in-law gave us; do we have the right to object to him?
Accepting help does not mean handing over every decision about your own life. However, financial dependence makes setting boundaries harder. That is why it is important to talk openly about what is expected in return for the help, and to make a long-term plan towards independence.
My father-in-law is very harsh with my children; what should I do?
Your child's safety and emotional health come first. Agree on a shared stance with your spouse and convey it to your father-in-law calmly but clearly: "We don't want our children to be shouted at; we will guide them ourselves." If this stance is constantly ignored, it may be necessary to limit the time the children spend alone with their grandfather.
I get on well with my mother-in-law, but I don't want to go to their home because of my father-in-law; what can I do?
Maintaining your relationship with your mother-in-law in settings where your father-in-law is not present may be an option: meeting outside, hosting her at your home or making short visits during the day. Rather than giving up family gatherings entirely, shortening them can also reduce the tension.
My husband works in his father's business and has no say at all; will this affect our marriage?
It may, because submission at work carries over into the home, and your husband may begin to feel he has no say in his own life either. It may help for your husband to discuss a written or clearly agreed job description with his father, to clarify his role and boundaries at work. In the longer term, considering other options is also something the couple can talk about together.
Bu yazı genel bilgilendirme amaçlıdır; tanı veya tedavi yerine geçmez. Yaşadığınız güçlükler için bir ruh sağlığı uzmanına başvurmanız önerilir. Acil bir durumda lütfen 112'yi arayın.
Eda Erkan Alapala
Klinik Psikolog. İstanbul Kent Üniversitesi Klinik Psikoloji Tezli Yüksek Lisans mezunu; bilişsel davranışçı terapi, çocuk merkezli oyun terapisi ve çocuk-ergen psikoterapisi alanlarında eğitimlerini tamamlamıştır.
Eğitimler
