Elderly Parent Refuses to See a Doctor: Persuading Without a Battle of Wills

How do you talk to an elderly parent who refuses to see a doctor? Read about the fears behind refusal, approaches that protect dignity and when not to wait.

In recent months your father has been getting out of breath more quickly and stopping halfway up the stairs. Your mother's hands tremble, or she coughs often while eating. When you say "Let's get you seen by a doctor", the answer is always the same: "There's nothing wrong with me", "Those doctors make you ill", "What can they do at my age?" The longer the conversation goes on, the louder the voices get, and in the end you both part feeling hurt. Many adult children whose elderly parent refuses to see a doctor find themselves stuck between worry and helplessness. In this article I look at why older people may refuse to see a doctor, how to talk about it without it turning into a battle of wills, how to support them while protecting their dignity and autonomy, and in which situations you need to act without waiting.

Why Do Older People Refuse to See a Doctor?

Behind refusal there are usually feelings far more complex than stubbornness. Understanding the reason is the first step towards finding the right approach.

Fear of bad news

The thought "If I go, they'll find something" is a common reason for avoidance in older people. Not knowing can sometimes feel safer than knowing. This fear is especially pronounced in older people who have seen serious illness or loss around them. I have discussed this form of avoidance in detail in the article on fear of going to the doctor.

Worry about losing independence

For an older person, a diagnosis can mean losing their driving licence, living alone in their own home, tending their garden or making their own decisions. Worries such as "If I go to the doctor they'll shut me away somewhere" or "My children will start interfering in everything" make it easier to ignore symptoms.

Not wanting to be a burden

Many older people feel uncomfortable about their children leaving their work to take them to hospital or spending money on them. The sentence "I don't want to put you to any trouble" is really an expression of love and shame together. In this case, framing a visit to the doctor not as a "burden" but as a kindness done for the family's peace of mind can help: "I'm worn out from worrying about you; if you go, we'll all feel easier."

Past experiences and difficulties with the system

Long queues, the difficulty of getting an appointment, getting lost in hospital corridors and being examined hurriedly without being understood can drive older people away from doctors. Not knowing how to book an appointment by phone or online, or being unable to understand the doctor because of hearing difficulties, makes the process even more wearing.

Views on old age and death

Thoughts such as "What difference does it make at my age?" or "When your time comes, it comes" may appear in some older people as fatalism or resignation. This outlook sometimes reflects genuine peace and acceptance, and sometimes may be a sign of low mood. To understand the difference, it helps to look at how the older person views the rest of life: are they still taking an interest in their grandchildren, working in their garden, chatting with people, or are they withdrawing from everything?

Depression and cognitive changes

Depression in later life can show itself through giving up on self-care, lack of motivation and the thought "What difference does it make?"; I have described this in the article on depression in older adults. In addition, with cognitive changes such as dementia, the person may not realise they have a problem. In this case, refusal may not be stubbornness but part of the illness.

How Should You Talk When an Elderly Parent Refuses to See a Doctor?

Choose the time and place

Raising this subject at a Bayram (religious holiday) meal, at a crowded family gathering or in the middle of an argument makes the older person feel cornered. Talking one to one, at a calm moment, for example over a cup of tea or on a walk, is more productive.

Listen first, then talk

It is important to ask "Why don't you want to go?" in a tone of genuine curiosity rather than interrogation. Listen without trying to correct the answer. Rather than saying "What is there to be afraid of?" to someone who says "I'm afraid of the hospital", saying "What is it about it that frightens you, will you tell me?" opens the conversation.

Express your worry with "I" statements

The sentence "You never look after yourself" is heard as an accusation. The sentence "When I see you struggling on the stairs I get worried, I'm afraid of losing you" shares your feeling and reduces the need to become defensive.

Offer choices

Rather than taking the decision away from them entirely, let them choose between options: "Would you rather go to the family doctor or to the doctor at the hospital?", "Is Tuesday better, or Thursday?", "Would you like to come with me or with my sister?" Being able to choose preserves a sense of control. Leaving small decisions to them can also make it easier for them to accept the big one.

Start with small steps

A comprehensive hospital check-up can be daunting. Instead, smaller steps can be suggested, such as just having their blood pressure taken, a short visit to the family doctor or getting information about home healthcare services.

Avoid a battle of wills

In a relationship where every conversation turns into an argument, the older person may start to see the doctor issue as "a war to be won against their children". When a conversation goes badly, stepping back and trying again another day is far more effective than insisting.

Suppose a man in his seventies has been coughing every morning for months and brushes off each of his daughter's suggestions to see a doctor with "It's the cigarettes, it'll pass." One day, instead of arguing, his daughter asks him: "Dad, what bothers you most about going to the doctor?" Her father is silent for a while, then admits: "They'll tell me to stop smoking, and if I can't, how will I face them?" The real obstacle is not fear of illness but the shame of being judged. Once this is noticed, the conversation changes too: "The doctor won't be looking at you to judge you, but so that you can breathe more easily. If you like, I'll tell them that right at the start."

What Should and Shouldn't Be Said?

The sentences below are fictional examples.

Words that can intensify the battle of wills:

• "Stop acting like a child, get up, we're going."
• "If something happens to you later, don't come to us."
• "The neighbour's husband was stubborn like this too, and in the end he died."
• "You don't know, we do."

Words that can open up the conversation:

• "The decision is yours, but because I care about you so much I want to tell you that I'm worried."
• "What's the hardest part of going to the doctor for you?"
• "I'll come with you and take care of all the paperwork; you'll only need to talk to the doctor."
• "If nothing is found, we'll be able to relax; and if something is, we'll decide together what to do."

If an Elderly Parent Who Refuses to See a Doctor Lives Alone

In older people who have lost their spouse and live alone, avoiding doctors can be more frequent and go unnoticed for longer. When the person who would be first to notice symptoms is not in the house, problems only come to light once they have progressed. Moreover, for an older person living alone, going to hospital is a tiring journey that has to be made without asking anyone for help.

In such cases, regular visits and phone calls are not only social support but also a way of noticing changes. Signs such as weight loss, an empty fridge, the house becoming disordered or asking the same questions over and over are changes worth paying attention to. Keeping in touch with neighbours, the building caretaker or a trusted local shopkeeper also widens the safety net. To make sure the older person feels cared about rather than watched, this attention needs to be maintained with respect for their privacy.

Removing Practical Obstacles

Sometimes the real reason behind refusal is not emotional but practical. Removing these obstacles can be easier than persuading.

• Take on appointments and paperwork. Tell them that you will handle tasks such as booking the appointment, waiting in queues and following up test results.
• Make getting there easier. Talk in advance about worries such as how to get to the hospital, where to wait and whether there are stairs.
• Go to the appointment prepared. Write down together on a piece of paper their symptoms, the medicines they use and the questions they want to ask. This reduces the older person's worry about forgetting what to say in front of the doctor.
• Take hearing and sight difficulties into account. If necessary, ask the doctor to speak slowly and clearly; but during the examination do not speak on the older person's behalf, leave them room to speak.
• Bring in people they trust. Some older people listen more easily to a suggestion coming not from their children but from a family doctor they have known for many years, a grandchild or a close friend.
• Look into home healthcare services. For older people with mobility difficulties, home healthcare may be available in some areas. You can get information about this from the family doctor.

The way to persuade an elderly parent who refuses to see a doctor is not to defeat them, but to understand their fear and let them feel that you are standing by them.

Between Autonomy and Responsibility

Like any adult whose capacity to make decisions is intact, older people have the right to make decisions about their own health; this sometimes includes decisions you do not approve of. This is hard to accept, but accepting it protects the relationship. Sometimes all you can do is state your worry openly, leave the door open and keep loving them despite their decision. I have discussed respect for an older person's decisions in detail in the article on autonomy in older patients.

In some situations, however, the picture changes. If there are cognitive changes such as forgetfulness, confusion or the person being unable to recognise that they have a problem, the older person's capacity to make decisions may be affected. In such a case, it is necessary to plan how to proceed by talking to the family doctor or the relevant specialist.

Disagreements between siblings are also common: one may say "Let's take them by force" while another says "Let's not interfere". Siblings first agreeing on a shared approach among themselves and approaching the older person with one voice stops them feeling besieged. Sharing tasks also helps: one sibling can arrange the appointment while another accompanies them to hospital, and a sibling who lives far away can offer moral support by phone. That way no sibling builds up anger with the feeling "Everything is on me", and the older person does not feel they have become a subject of disagreement among their children. Putting the older person's own wishes on the table when agreeing a shared approach makes them the subject of the decision rather than its object.

Situations Where You Should Not Wait

Allowing time for persuasion is appropriate in most cases; but some symptoms require urgent intervention. In situations such as chest pain, sudden shortness of breath, drooping of the face, sudden weakness in an arm or leg, sudden difficulty speaking, clouding of consciousness, a serious fall, or confusion accompanied by a high temperature, call 112 (emergency services) without getting into an argument. If an older person says things like "I want to die" or "I don't want to live any more", or talks about thoughts of harming themselves, this too must be taken seriously; in an emergency, again call 112.

When Should You Seek Professional Support?

Refusing to see a doctor is sometimes a sign of a deeper problem. It may help for the older person or the family to get support from a mental health professional in the following situations:

• The older person has seemed unmotivated, withdrawn or hopeless for a long time
• They have stopped eating, looking after themselves or leaving the house
• Intense anxiety or avoidance relating to illness and death
• Family conflicts about the issue seriously wearing down relationships
• The adult child experiencing intense guilt, anger or burnout

For adult children, individual therapy offers a space to talk about anxiety, boundaries and guilt in their relationship with an ageing parent. In work with the older person themselves, anxiety and avoidance, losses, beliefs about ageing and depressive symptoms can be addressed. If depressive symptoms are pronounced, an assessment by a psychiatrist is also important.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I take my elderly father to the doctor by force?

Forcing an adult whose capacity to make decisions is intact is problematic both ethically and for the relationship, and it usually damages trust. If there is a medical emergency, you need to call 112. If you suspect a cognitive problem, you can talk to your family doctor about how to proceed.

My mother goes to the doctor but doesn't follow what she's told, what should I do?

First try to understand why: is she wary of side effects, is she mixing up the instructions, or does she think the recommendations are unnecessary? Passing these concerns on to her doctor together with her is much safer than her simply stopping on her own.

I live far away, how can I persuade my elderly mother to see a doctor?

When you talk on the phone, share your curiosity and worry rather than putting on pressure. You can ask a trusted relative or neighbour who lives near your mother for support, and handle the appointment arrangements yourself from a distance. Accompanying her by video call on the day of the check-up also reduces her sense of loneliness.

My elderly mother says "I know better than the doctor", how should I approach this?

A long life's experience gives an older person the feeling that they know their own body well, and this feeling is often justified. Involving her knowledge in the process works better than belittling it: "You know your body well, and you can tell the doctor that; together you'll find a way." An older person who feels consulted may be more open to the suggestion.

• #ageing parents
• #health in later life
• #family communication
• #autonomy in older adults

Yazar

Eda Erkan Alapala

Klinik Psikolog. İstanbul Kent Üniversitesi Klinik Psikoloji Tezli Yüksek Lisans mezunu; bilişsel davranışçı terapi, çocuk merkezli oyun terapisi ve çocuk-ergen psikoterapisi alanlarında eğitimlerini tamamlamıştır.

Eğitimler