Therapy Not Working? What to Do When It Feels Ineffective

Feeling that therapy is not working? Learn the reasons behind this feeling, how to talk to your therapist and ways to bring the process back to life.

You have been going to sessions regularly for weeks, perhaps months, but one morning you find yourself thinking, "Therapy isn't working. Am I wasting my time?" This thought is a deeply human feeling that many people meet at some point in the therapy process. Sometimes it points to something that genuinely needs to change; sometimes it shows that you have entered the hardest but most productive phase of change. In this article we look at the possible causes of this feeling, how you can assess the situation, how you can talk to your therapist and, if necessary, which steps you can take.

What Does the Feeling That "Therapy Isn't Working" Mean?

Progress in therapy rarely moves in a straight line. In the first sessions, the relief of talking, the hope of being understood and the excitement of a new beginning often create a strong sense of improvement. Then, when the real work begins, this initial effect fades. Old habits push back, difficult emotions surface, and a person may feel even worse than when they started.

For this reason, the feeling that therapy "isn't working" does not carry a single meaning. Roughly speaking, there are three possibilities:

• The natural ups and downs of change: The process is moving forward, but the progress is too slow to notice at the moment, or it comes with ups and downs.
• A stuck point that can be resolved: The goals have become unclear, the method no longer fits your needs, or there is an important subject that is not being talked about. This often gets better with an open conversation.
• A genuine mismatch: Your therapist's approach, area of expertise or way of communicating does not fit your needs. In this case a change may be necessary.

To work out which one applies, it helps first to review the situation calmly.

Why Can Therapy Feel Like It Isn't Working?

There can be many different reasons behind the feeling that therapy is not having the expected effect. Some relate to the process, some to life circumstances and some to expectations.

Your goals may have become unclear

In therapy that begins with a general goal such as "I want to feel better", it is hard to measure progress. If it is not clear what needs to change, it becomes harder to notice what has changed. Sometimes there is real progress, but it stays invisible because there is no yardstick.

Your expectations may be unrealistic

Expecting therapy to solve a problem that has lasted for years in a few sessions inevitably leads to disappointment. In the same way, if you expect your therapist to tell you what to do and to make decisions about your life, a process based on exploration may feel unproductive.

Approaching difficult emotions can make things temporarily worse

When you begin talking about a memory you have avoided for a long time, an experience of shame or a loss, you are likely to feel more intense emotions for a while. This does not mean that therapy is causing harm; it often shows that something suppressed is finally beginning to be processed. Even so, it is important that this period is handled together with your therapist, at a safe pace.

Very little may be changing between sessions

A one-hour weekly session is a small slice of time next to the remaining hundred and sixty-odd hours of the week. If what is discussed in the session is not tried out in daily life, what you learn struggles to become lasting.

Your life circumstances may have become heavier

External events such as losing a job, financial difficulties, illness, moving house, relationship crises or the loss of a loved one can overshadow the work done in therapy. Even if progress seems to have stopped during these periods, therapy may be acting as an anchor that stops things getting worse.

There may be a problem in the therapeutic relationship

If you feel judged, misunderstood or unsafe, it becomes hard to open up the most important subjects. Research shows that the quality of the therapeutic relationship is one of the most consistent factors influencing the outcome of therapy. We covered this subject in more detail in the article on the therapeutic relationship and therapist fit.

Questions you can ask yourself to assess the situation

Before talking to your therapist, it can be useful to clarify your own thoughts. Try writing the following questions on a piece of paper and answering them:

1. What did I want to change when I first started therapy? Is that goal still valid?
2. Since the beginning, has anything changed, however small? Has anyone around me said they noticed a difference?
3. Can I talk about the really important subjects in sessions, or am I avoiding some of them?
4. Do I get the chance to put what I have learned into practice between sessions?
5. Do I feel safe and respected when I am with my therapist?
6. Is there an unusual event in my life at this time that is making the process harder?
7. What would need to happen for me to say "it's working"?

Let's say that while answering these questions you notice that your sleep has improved but the cycle of jealousy in your relationship has not changed at all. In that case it would be more accurate to say not that therapy is not working at all, but that you are stuck in one particular area. This distinction also makes the conversation you will have with your therapist far more productive.

One of the most valuable conversations in therapy is the one about therapy itself.

How Can You Talk to Your Therapist If You Think Therapy Isn't Working?

Many people hesitate to tell their therapist about this feeling. Worries such as "Will they be hurt, will they think I'm ungrateful, will it damage our relationship?" are very common. Yet for an experienced therapist, this feedback is valuable information; it is the most direct way of readjusting the process. Being able to express what you feel in therapy can even be an important therapeutic experience in its own right. If you are someone who always puts your own needs in the background so as not to hurt others, this conversation also works as practice for the relationships in your everyday life.

To make the conversation easier, you can try the following steps:

• Bring it up at the start of the session. Instead of leaving it to the last five minutes, saying "Today I'd like to talk about the process" at the beginning ensures enough time is set aside.
• Be specific. Instead of "Nothing is changing", share observations such as "I was hoping my anxiety would be lower, but I'm still avoiding meetings".
• Say what you need. Express needs such as more structure, more practical tools, more focus on the past, or, conversely, a wish to return to the present.
• Review the goals together. Suggest revisiting and updating the goals you set at the start.
• Set a time for a review. Agree on a time, after a few sessions, to come back to the question "How is it going?"

After this conversation, your therapist may change their approach, suggest different techniques, make progress more concrete with measurement tools or, if necessary, refer you to another specialist.

Practical Tips to Revive the Process

Besides talking to your therapist, there are steps you can take on your own side:

1. Keep a "therapy notebook". After each session, note down a sentence that stayed with you, an idea or a behaviour you want to try. Also write down the moments you struggled with during the week and bring them to the next session.
2. Protect the five minutes after your session. Instead of going straight back to your phone or work, take a short walk and give yourself time to take in what was discussed.
3. Run small experiments. Test an idea discussed in the session with a small step in daily life. For example, if you are working on the belief "If I say no, everyone will be upset with me", try saying no once in a low-risk situation and observe what happens.
4. Measure progress. Once a week, rate the symptom that brought you to therapy from zero to ten. Looking at these scores after a few weeks may reveal a different picture from the one you feel.
5. Review your basic needs. Sleep, nutrition, movement and social connection directly support the effect of therapy. If these are seriously lacking, the work done in therapy also becomes harder.
6. Keep to your session schedule. Frequent cancellations and long gaps reduce the momentum of progress.

When Is Changing Therapist the Right Thing to Do?

Sometimes, despite an open conversation and a trial of a few sessions, the picture does not change. In such cases, changing therapist or trying a different approach can be a healthy decision. The following signs may mean you should consider this:

• If you feel your feedback is not taken seriously and is met with a defensive or dismissive attitude,
• If the therapist does not have the necessary training or experience for the problem you are living with,
• If you constantly feel judged, shamed or unsafe in sessions,
• If you encounter worrying situations around confidentiality, boundaries or professional ethics.

Changing therapist is not a failure. It shows that you take your own needs seriously. If possible, doing this by talking it through with your current therapist and having a closing session helps you take what you have gained with you. When looking for a new specialist, the criteria in the article on how to choose a psychologist may be useful.

In some cases, too, the problem is less the therapist than the fact that psychotherapy alone is not enough. For example, if there are severe depressive symptoms, long-standing sleep problems or anxiety that seriously affects daily functioning, an assessment by a psychiatrist can make a complementary contribution to the process.

When Should You Seek Professional Support?

If your symptoms are getting noticeably worse while you continue therapy, tell your therapist straight away; you do not have to wait for the next session. The following situations in particular may call for additional assessment:

• If your sense of hopelessness is deepening and your belief that nothing will change is getting stronger,
• If you are finding it increasingly hard to manage daily tasks or to go to work or school,
• If your alcohol or substance use has increased,
• If thoughts of harming yourself or ending your life cross your mind.

If the last point applies, do not wait; in an emergency call 112 (emergency services) or go to your nearest emergency department. The question of whether therapy is working can be discussed once your safety has been ensured.

If you are not yet in therapy and feel hesitant about starting again because of a negative therapy experience in the past, sharing that experience openly in the first session can help the new process begin on a better footing. In individual therapy, talking about what did and did not work in your previous experiences is a valuable starting point for setting the roadmap of the new work.

How Is Feeling Stuck Handled in Therapy?

Feeling stuck in therapy is an expected part of professional work, and therapists are trained to work with these situations. In cognitive behavioural therapy, because the process is built on jointly agreed goals and regular measurement, getting stuck is usually noticed quickly. The therapist and client go back together to the case formulation: Is our first understanding of why the problem continues still correct? Is there a cycle we have overlooked? Are avoidance behaviours blocking progress? When these questions are answered afresh, a new path often opens up.

A schema-focused perspective also helps in understanding feeling stuck. For example, a client with a defectiveness or emotional deprivation schema may perceive even their therapist's care through familiar patterns such as "one day they'll leave me" or "they don't really understand me". Noticing and talking about this pattern within the therapy relationship creates a powerful learning opportunity that also carries over into relationships in everyday life. In this way, the feeling that "it isn't working" can sometimes become one of the most productive turning points of the process.

Sometimes getting stuck also calls for a change of method. Adding couple or family sessions alongside individual work, putting more weight on exposure work, using emotion-focused techniques or rearranging the frequency of sessions are among the options. What matters is that these decisions are made together with the client and with open communication.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal to feel worse after starting therapy?

Especially when approaching difficult memories or feelings you have avoided for a long time, it is possible to feel more intense emotions for a while. This is not always a negative sign, but it should be talked through with your therapist and the pace adjusted together. If the worsening lasts a long time or threatens your safety, additional assessment is needed.

Will my therapist be hurt if I tell them therapy isn't working?

An experienced therapist uses this kind of feedback to improve the process and does not take it as a personal attack. Indeed, many therapists deliberately encourage regular feedback from their clients. If you meet a defensive reaction when you say it, that too is information you can take into account when making your assessment.

After how many sessions should I decide?

It would not be right to give an exact number, because this varies with the issue being worked on and the approach. Generally, after a few sessions you can assess whether a sense of trust has formed between you and your therapist, and after a few months whether there is movement towards the goals. It is best to discuss this question directly with your therapist.

If therapy isn't working, is something wrong with me?

No. Therapy getting stuck does not mean a person is "beyond help". More often it points to the need to review the method, the goals, the timing or the fit with the therapist. Many people experience meaningful change with a different approach or a restructured process.

• #therapy process
• #feeling stuck in therapy
• #changing therapist
• #therapeutic relationship

Yazar

Eda Erkan Alapala

Klinik Psikolog. İstanbul Kent Üniversitesi Klinik Psikoloji Tezli Yüksek Lisans mezunu; bilişsel davranışçı terapi, çocuk merkezli oyun terapisi ve çocuk-ergen psikoterapisi alanlarında eğitimlerini tamamlamıştır.

Eğitimler