Teenager Who Can't Handle Losing: Intolerance of Failure and Criticism

Why does a teenager who can't handle losing fall apart over a small mistake? Explore the roots of intolerance of failure and criticism and how families help.

A young person who cries for hours in the changing room after missing a last-second shot in a basketball match, who throws their medal to the bottom of their bag because they came second in a chess tournament, who tears up their notebook saying "I can't do anything right anyway" because of a single correction their teacher wrote on an essay... A teenager who can't handle losing leaves their family both surprised and helpless. The parent often sees that the reaction is out of proportion to the event, yet also senses that the young person's pain is real. Defeat, criticism and mistakes are inevitable parts of life, and adolescence is one of the most important periods for learning to cope with them. In this article we look at the inner world of a young person who falls apart after a small failure, where this reaction comes from, and how the family can support them without either overprotecting them or leaving them alone.

What Does a Teenager Who Can't Handle Losing Go Through?

For most people, a defeat brings disappointment and a short-lived sadness. For a teenager who can't handle losing, however, a defeat is not just the outcome of an event but something like a verdict passed on themselves. The thought "I lost the match" quickly turns into the belief "I am a failure."

Common reactions in these young people include:

• Intense anger, crying fits or damaging things after losing
• Withdrawing for a long time and not wanting to talk to anyone
• Blaming the referee, the teacher, teammates or luck
• Not taking part at all in competitions, exams or activities they think they cannot win
• Becoming defensive at the slightest criticism, or putting themselves down excessively
• Not starting a task at all if they cannot do it "perfectly"
• Being unable to relax even when they succeed, immediately focusing anxiously on the next goal

Some of these reactions are directed outwards (anger, blame) and some inwards (shame, withdrawal). Both forms are fed by the same underlying difficulty: the young person's worth has become tied to the results they produce.

Why Does Intolerance of Failure Develop?

There is no single cause of extreme sensitivity to losing. Usually several factors come together.

Temperament and emotional intensity

Some young people feel things more intensely by nature. Their joys and their sorrows are both strong. For these young people, digesting a defeat can take longer than for peers with a calmer temperament.

Perfectionism

A young person who expects flawless performance from themselves may experience even a "good" result as a failure. In an exam where they scored ninety-five, the five points lost stay in their mind more than the ninety-five gained. Our article on perfectionism offers detailed information about its different faces.

Worth tied to success

When a young person is known above all for their achievements in the family, at school or in their wider circle, they may come to believe that being loved and admired depends on being successful. For a young person whose family boasts "Our boy always comes first", coming second is not just a ranking but a loss of identity.

Having always won early on

Young people who achieved easy success throughout childhood and rarely faced difficulty may be caught unprepared when they meet serious competition for the first time in adolescence. A young person who was the star of their class in middle school and then moves to a selective science high school may experience a real shock when they realise they are an average student there.

The parent's attitude to mistakes

How a parent responds to their own mistakes is also decisive. Parents who criticise themselves harshly when they get something wrong, and who talk about losing as if it were shameful, may unknowingly pass the same attitude on to the young person.

An intensely competitive environment

In Turkey, centralised exams such as LGS and YKS (Turkey's national high-school and university entrance exams) create an environment where rankings, percentile bands and mock-exam scores are constantly discussed. In a system where a handful of correct answers can make a big difference to university placement, a young person may experience every small drop as a disaster. For many young people growing up in this environment, "losing" starts to mean losing their future.

How Does Intolerance of Criticism Affect Daily Life?

For a teenager who can't handle losing, it is not only competitions but many areas of everyday life that can become challenging.

At school: A teacher's feedback may be perceived as a personal attack. The young person may avoid asking questions in class or putting their hand up for questions they might get wrong. Oral presentations, project competitions or lab work can become sources of anxiety.

In friendships: Losing a game or an argument can create tension with friends. Some young people try to change the rules of the game because they always want to win, while others do not join in at all. Over time this can lead to loneliness.

In sport and the arts: An activity the young person loves can turn into a burden once the pressure to win comes in. Many young people want to give up a sport or instrument they have kept up for years because they are afraid of losing.

In the family: Even a simple reminder from a parent such as "You haven't tidied your room this week" can trigger the feeling "I can't do anything right" and turn into an argument.

Let's say a seventeen-year-old girl spends months preparing for a science olympiad and is eliminated in the first round. On the evening the results are announced she does not come down for dinner, the next day she does not want to go to school, and she throws all her study notes in the bin. As the weeks pass, her motivation in other subjects drops too, because the belief "I'm not good enough at anything anyway" has spread to every area. In a picture like this, what the young person is going through is not just an elimination but a shaking of their beliefs about themselves.

At this point, the family quickly closing the subject with "You can enter again next year", or belittling the effort with "You didn't need to work that hard anyway", may not help the young person. A teenager who can't handle losing first needs the size of their disappointment to be seen. Only once it has been seen can they become open to conversations about what comes next.

What Can the Family Do for a Teenager Who Can't Handle Losing?

The parent's aim here is not to protect the young person from defeat, but to accompany them as they learn to cope with it.

Don't belittle the feeling, but don't amplify it either

Saying "What's there to be upset about, it's only a match" invalidates what the young person is going through. On the other hand, getting excessively angry along with them or blaming the referee makes the reaction grow. A sentence such as "This has really upset you, you put so much work into it" acknowledges the feeling while keeping things calm.

Don't rush to draw lessons

Saying "Look, if you'd done this you would have won" straight after a defeat makes the young person hear these words as criticism. First let the feeling settle; you can talk it through a few days later, when the young person is ready.

Make effort and process visible

Questions like "How did you prepare for this exam?" or "What were you proudest of in this match?" instead of "What score did you get?" turn the young person's attention from the result to the process. Talking about effort, strategy and progress shows that worth is not measured by results alone.

Share your own mistakes

When you miss a deadline on a project at work, burn a meal or a decision of yours turns out to be wrong, sharing this with the young person and showing how you recovered teaches that making mistakes does not make a person worthless.

Make room for the experience of losing

Keeping a young person away from difficult competitions to stop them losing protects them in the short term but prevents their coping skills from developing in the long term. Losing in low-stakes settings, such as board games within the family or friendly matches in a sport, and getting through it together, is valuable practice.

Separate your love from their success

The young person should feel that they are worth just as much in your eyes on the days they lose. On report card day, asking "How did this term go, how are you?" before looking at the marks is a small but powerful message. Not introducing the young person only by their grades and rankings during visits to relatives supports the same message.

Losing shows the result of that day, not the young person's worth. A young person who learns this distinction can find the courage to try again.

For Young People: How Can You Treat Yourself After a Defeat?

You may be a young person reading this article. If storms break out inside you when you lose a match, an exam or a competition, it does not mean you are weak; it most likely shows that you put effort into something you care about deeply. Even so, it is possible to make that storm a little more manageable.

• Give your feeling a name: Saying "I feel really ashamed right now" or "I'm very angry with myself" helps you see the feeling from a little distance.
• Don't make big decisions in the first twenty-four hours: Decisions made right after a defeat, such as "I'm quitting this sport" or "I'll never enter a competition again", are usually the product of intense emotion. Waiting a day lets you think more clearly.
• How would you talk to a friend? If your closest friend had the same result, would you tell them "You're nothing"? Try treating yourself the way you would treat that friend.
• Don't generalise one result to your whole life: A mock exam, an elimination or a match only describes that day. It does not describe who you are, what you love or what you are capable of.
• Calm yourself physically: A short walk, a shower, listening to music you love or breathing slowly can calm your body before your mind settles.
• Talk: Sharing what you are going through with a parent, coach, teacher or friend you trust means you do not have to carry the weight alone.

When Should You Seek Professional Support?

Being upset and angry after a defeat is natural. However, in the following situations it can be helpful to get support from a professional:

• If reactions are clearly out of proportion to the event and happen often
• If the young person stops taking part in exams, lessons or activities they love out of fear of failing
• If they harm themselves or those around them when they lose
• If there is prolonged unhappiness, hopelessness, or changes in sleep and appetite
• If they say things like "I'm useless" or "There's no point in me living"
• If they experience intense physical symptoms of anxiety during exam periods

If a young person talks about harming themselves or ending their life, take these statements seriously and, in an emergency, call 112 (emergency services) without delay. Our article on exam anxiety may also offer guidance on anxiety during exam periods.

How Are Intolerance of Failure and Criticism Addressed in Therapy?

In adolescent counselling, the first step is to understand together what the young person feels and thinks when faced with defeat and criticism.

In Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, thought patterns such as "If I lost, I'm worthless", "If I make a mistake, everyone will laugh at me" and "All or nothing" are identified. The young person learns to weigh up the evidence for these thoughts and to develop more flexible and realistic alternatives. Gradually approaching the situations they avoid and testing the consequences of making mistakes in real life are also an important part of the work.

From a schema-focused perspective, young people who react strongly to losing often show early patterns known as "unrelenting standards/hypercriticalness" or "failure". These patterns make the young person's inner voice towards themselves very harsh. In therapy, an effort is made to understand where this inner voice comes from and to develop a more compassionate one in its place.

Emotion regulation skills are also important in this process. In moments of intense anger or shame, techniques such as breathing exercises, taking a short break and naming the emotion help the young person soothe themselves.

In sessions with parents, messages about success at home, the language of praise and the family's attitude towards mistakes are reviewed. Our article on pressure on high-achieving students may also offer families a different perspective on how expectations of success are reflected onto the young person.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does being unable to handle losing pass?

In many young people, tolerance of defeat develops as they get older and gain experience. However, this development happens more easily in environments where the young person can experience that making mistakes is safe; that is why the attitude of the family and the school matters.

Should I stop entering my teenager into competitions?

Keeping them away from competitions entirely also removes the opportunity to learn how to cope with losing. Experiences in areas the young person is interested in, where pressure is kept low and the process is talked about, are usually more helpful.

What does it mean when they blame the referee or the teacher after losing?

Blame is often a way for the young person to protect themselves from the shame and disappointment they feel. Rather than trying to correct this reaction immediately, it is more effective first to acknowledge the feeling, and then, at a calm moment, to help them think about their own part.

Does praise make a young person more resilient to failure?

The type of praise matters. Praise aimed at personality, such as "You're so clever", can make a young person more afraid of making mistakes, whereas concrete feedback about effort, strategy and progress supports resilience.

• #failure
• #criticism
• #perfectionism
• #adolescent psychology

Yazar

Eda Erkan Alapala

Klinik Psikolog. İstanbul Kent Üniversitesi Klinik Psikoloji Tezli Yüksek Lisans mezunu; bilişsel davranışçı terapi, çocuk merkezli oyun terapisi ve çocuk-ergen psikoterapisi alanlarında eğitimlerini tamamlamıştır.

Eğitimler