Drama for Shy Children: Courage Through Play, Not on Stage

Can a drama class help a shy child? Creative drama versus stage training, supporting your child without pushing, and the warning signs to watch for.

As the 23 April show approaches (National Sovereignty and Children's Day, when Turkish schools stage performances), the teacher hands out roles in class. Some children shoot their hands up and shout, "I want to be the king!"; others shrink down towards their desks, holding their breath so that their name will not be called. That evening, the mother of one of these children remembers a friend's suggestion: "Sign her up for a drama class; it'll bring her out of her shell." Is drama really good for a shy child, or does it become an experience that makes things even harder? The answer depends largely on what kind of drama and what kind of approach we are talking about. In this article we talk about what shyness is, the difference between creative drama and stage training, how you can support your child without pushing them, and in which situations it would be helpful to consult a professional.

What Shyness Is and What It Isn't

Shyness is a temperamental trait that shows itself as reticence, caution and a need to observe for a while when meeting new people or new situations. A shy child may first hide behind their mother's legs on arriving at a birthday party, may prefer to watch for a while before joining a game, and may stay silent when an unfamiliar adult asks them a question.

This trait is not a problem in itself. Many shy children relax once they get used to a setting, form close friendships and, over time, develop social skills in their own way. Shyness can also go together with strengths such as careful observation, sensitivity to other people's feelings and acting thoughtfully.

In our culture, shy children sometimes face extra pressure. At bayram (religious holiday) visits, sentences such as "Come on, recite a poem for your uncle" or "Why aren't you saying hello to your auntie? That's rude", however well-meant, can push a child into the spotlight. A child expected to speak in a crowded sitting room with everyone's eyes on them may experience these moments like an exam. When a parent stands by the child in such situations, giving them time by saying, for example, "She'll come over once she's settled; for now she's sitting with me," the child feels protected. This is not giving up on teaching good manners; it means teaching them at a pace the child is ready for. A forced greeting usually leaves a child not with courage but with shame.

In some cases, however, reticence can turn into anxiety that clearly restricts the child's daily life. Not speaking at all at school, being unable to make friends, intensely avoiding social situations, or showing physical reactions such as stomach aches or crying in these situations may point to a difficulty that goes beyond shyness. We have discussed the difference between shyness and social anxiety in detail in our article on the shy child.

Drama for Shy Children: Which Kind of Drama?

The word "drama" covers different practices, and these differences directly affect the quality of the experience for a shy child.

Creative drama

Creative drama is an educational approach in which children, within a group, experience a situation, a role or a story by acting it out through play and improvisation. The aim here is not to prepare a performance but the process itself. There is no audience; everyone is both actor and spectator. No "good" or "bad" performance comes out of it. We have described creative drama more fully in our article what is creative drama.

Stage and theatre training

Theatre classes, by contrast, are usually geared towards staging a play, learning lines and performing in front of an audience. These classes can be very valuable for children interested in the performing arts. For a shy child, however, especially at the start, the expectation of appearing in front of an audience can be a source of intense pressure.

Drama therapy and psychodrama

Drama therapy and psychodrama are approaches with therapeutic rather than educational aims. Jacob Levy Moreno, known as the founder of psychodrama, gave 1 April 1921, at the Komödienhaus in Vienna, as the method's birthday. In the history of drama-based therapies, Aristotle's idea that tragedy brings about a purification through pity and fear, known as "catharsis", is also often mentioned. These approaches are carried out within a therapeutic framework in which psychological difficulties are addressed, and they are not the same as a drama class.

In short, when drama is being considered for a shy child, the most suitable starting point is usually a play-based creative drama setting without stage pressure. Once the child begins to feel safe there, they can move on to theatre training later if they wish; the order is set by the child's readiness.

A shy child's courage grows not through applause on stage, but through feeling safe in play.

How Can Drama Help a Shy Child?

A well-run creative drama setting that respects the child's pace can be supportive for a shy child in several different ways:

• Speaking through someone else: taking on a role can allow a child to say, through a character, things they could not say as "me". Being a lion or a king can feel less frightening than being yourself.
• Experience in small steps: drama games often start with activities in which the whole group moves at the same time. The child can take part without being in the spotlight alone; over time the group can move on to smaller groups and then to pair work.
• A space where mistakes are safe: in improvisation there is no "wrong". This can be a reassuring experience for children who are perfectionist or afraid of being criticised.
• Expression through the body: children who struggle with verbal expression can also express themselves through gesture, facial expression and movement.
• A shared experience with peers: building a story together can lay the ground for a shy child to form a natural bond with their peers.

Imagine an eight-year-old boy who, in the first two weeks of a creative drama group, only watches from the corner. The leader does not push him, but in every game suggests small, quiet roles such as "You can be a tree if you like." In the third week the boy joins the game as a tree; in the fourth week he sways his branches when the wind blows, and when the other children laugh, he laughs too. A few months later, in an animal story, he asks of his own accord to say a short line. This does not mean his shyness has "gone away"; but it shows that he has experienced courage at his own pace in a safe setting. This example is fictional, and not every child will go through the same process.

What does the research say?

Strong evidence at the level of systematic reviews on the effect of creative drama and drama-based work on shy children is limited. A Cochrane review of drama therapy looked at a different area, schizophrenia, and concluded that benefit or harm was uncertain because of inadequate reporting. For psychodrama, too, no systematic review could be verified in the sources we consulted. It is therefore not possible to say that drama work will have a particular effect on shyness; but it can be thought of as offering new experiences in an enjoyable, safe setting that suits the child's pace.

What to Consider Before Signing Your Child Up for a Drama Class

If you are considering a drama class for a shy child, the following points can help you make your decision:

• Ask your child's opinion: drama should be an activity the child is curious about too. Asking "There's a place like this; shall we go and have a look together?" rather than "I've signed you up, you're going" gives the child a sense of control.
• Go to a trial lesson together: if possible, see the setting together at the first lesson. Some providers may allow a parent to stay in the room for a while during the first lessons.
• Ask about performance expectations: find out whether there is a show at the end of the course and whether taking part is compulsory. For a shy child, the right to choose not to take part in a show matters.
• Pay attention to group size: large groups can be more challenging for shy children.
• Watch your child's reactions: it is natural for them to be reticent in the first weeks. But if they experience intense anxiety, crying or stomach aches before every lesson, you may need to consider that this setting is not right for them at the moment.

Small steps through play at home

Before starting a drama class, or alongside one, you can also make room for your child at home through role play:

• Talking through puppets and toys: asking your child questions through a puppet or a soft toy can help them answer more easily.
• Role-swap games: games such as "Today you be the mum and I'll be the child" are fun and also let the child try out different points of view.
• Rehearsing difficult moments: act out together, through play, situations your child finds hard, such as going to the corner shop and asking for bread, or asking the teacher a question. Trying something out in play before the real situation can give a child confidence.
• Avoid labelling: saying "Ours is very shy" in front of the child can lead them to define themselves by that label. More flexible expressions can be used instead, such as "It takes her a little while to get used to new places."
• Notice small moments of courage: when your child says "Hello" to a guest of their own accord, show that you have noticed, sincerely but without making a fuss.
• Story-building games: after dinner, build a shared story in which everyone takes turns adding a sentence. The shy child knows in advance when it will be their turn and gets to enjoy contributing a single sentence. Knowing they have the right to say "pass" also makes taking part easier.

Drama at School: About Teachers and Performances

Shy children's first encounter with drama is often not a class but school. The 23 April and 29 October (Republic Day) shows or end-of-year performances are exciting for many children; for shy children, however, they can be a source of anxiety lasting weeks. Working together with the teacher during this period is very valuable.

When talking to the teacher, you might share the following points:

• That your child takes time to get used to new settings and crowds
• That roles in which they can take part within a group, such as a choir, a group dance or a poem recited together, may be less demanding for them than speaking alone on stage
• That letting them stand in the back rows at first during rehearsals may give them a chance to get used to things
• That if they are struggling a lot on the day, taking on a job behind the curtain rather than going on stage could also be an option

Many teachers are glad to take such information into account. Sometimes simply letting the child stand next to a friend they feel safe with can make a big difference. When the show is over, rather than evaluating your child's performance, you can show that you have noticed their effort by saying, "Being up there was hard for you, but you still took part." That small sentence can become a memory that goes with them the next time.

When Should You Seek Professional Support?

Shyness is usually a temperamental trait and softens over time as the child finds a balance in their own way. However, it may be helpful to consult a professional in the following situations:

• If the child has spoken hardly at all at school or outside the home for months
• If behaviours such as avoiding social situations or refusing to go to school clearly restrict daily life
• If physical reactions such as stomach aches, headaches, crying fits or sleep problems are frequent before social situations
• If the child has no friends at all, or is being excluded or bullied by peers
• If reticence increases rather than decreases as the child approaches adolescence

These signs alone do not amount to a diagnosis; but they deserve to be assessed in order to better understand the difficulty the child is experiencing. In child and play therapy, the child's feelings are addressed through age-appropriate means such as play, drawing and talking; cognitive behavioural methods for coping with anxiety and meetings with parents are also used. Where necessary, an assessment by a child psychiatrist may also be part of the process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will a drama class cure shyness?

There is no strong evidence that drama classes remove shyness, and shyness is not an illness that needs "curing" in the first place. A safe, play-based setting can help a child gain new experiences at their own pace.

Should I make my child perform in a show if they don't want to?

No. Pushing them can increase the child's anxiety and lead to a negative experience of drama. Taking part in the show in a different role away from the stage, such as helping to prepare the set, can also be an option.

Are creative drama and psychodrama the same thing?

No. Creative drama is an educational approach that aims to build experience through play. Psychodrama is a group therapy method carried out within a therapeutic framework in which psychological difficulties are addressed.

Is drama or sport better for a shy child?

There is no single right answer. What matters is a setting that interests the child, where they feel safe and where there is no excessive competition. Some children express themselves more comfortably in drama, some in team sports, and some in music or art.

• #shy child
• #creative drama
• #self-confidence in children
• #parent guide

Yazar

Eda Erkan Alapala

Klinik Psikolog. İstanbul Kent Üniversitesi Klinik Psikoloji Tezli Yüksek Lisans mezunu; bilişsel davranışçı terapi, çocuk merkezli oyun terapisi ve çocuk-ergen psikoterapisi alanlarında eğitimlerini tamamlamıştır.

Eğitimler