What Is Bibliotherapy? Ways Books Can Support You, and Their Limits

What is bibliotherapy, and how can reading support mental health? Read what research says, how to choose a book and where the method's limits lie.

You have probably glanced at the book in the hands of the person sitting next to you on the metro. Sometimes it is a novel, sometimes a poetry collection, and sometimes a guide with a title like "coping with anxiety" on the cover. People turn to books in difficult times; they find themselves in a character, underline a sentence, read a chapter over and over again. The question "what is bibliotherapy?" grows out of exactly this experience: does reading really help, or is it just a pleasant feeling? In this article we explain in detail what bibliotherapy is, its different forms, what research does and does not support, how you can use it on your own, and where a book will fall short. Our short answer is this: books can be valuable companions on the way; but not every book does the same job, and no book replaces professional support when it is needed.

What Is Bibliotherapy? A Short Definition

Bibliotherapy is the planned use of books and other written texts to help a person cope with an emotional, cognitive or behavioural difficulty. The word is derived from Greek roots meaning "book" and "treatment"; however, the name does not mean that a book on its own is a treatment.

The key word here is "planned". Not every book read at random counts as bibliotherapy. In bibliotherapy a text suited to the person's needs is chosen, the reading is done with a purpose, and what is read is reflected on and, where possible, talked about. This process may be carried out on the recommendation and with the follow-up of a mental health professional, or it may be a form of self-care that the person practises on their own. It is important to keep the difference in mind: a reading programme followed with a professional and reading novels in the evening to feel good are not the same thing. The latter is valuable too; but our expectations of it should be different. One is a process aimed at working on a particular problem, with goals and follow-up; the other is a habit that nourishes our mood in everyday life and offers enjoyment and rest. Both have their place, and they do not exclude each other.

Types of Bibliotherapy: From Guidebooks to Novels

Bibliotherapy is usually discussed under two main headings.

1. Structured (information-based) bibliotherapy

In this type, the person works with self-help books prepared for a particular problem area. These books are often based on the principles of cognitive behavioural therapy: they explain how a problem works and offer thought records, behaviour plans and step-by-step exercises. In a sense, the reader runs "a programme from a book". For example, a guide on anxiety might explain how avoidance behaviours feed anxiety and invite the reader to approach feared situations in small steps.

2. Creative (literary) bibliotherapy

In this type, literary texts such as novels, short stories, poetry or memoirs are used. The aim is less to provide information than to help the reader identify with a character, look at their own experience from the outside and put names to their feelings. A grieving person may recognise their own feelings in the inner world of a character who has suffered a loss. Someone who has migrated may feel less alone in a story about life far from home.

Picture books are also often used in work with children. A book dealing with topics such as the birth of a sibling, moving house, starting school or the loss of a loved one can open the door for a child to talk about their own experiences. We explain how you can help a child to love reading without pressure in our article on getting your child to love reading.

How Can Reading Help?

There are several ways in which a book can do a reader good:

• Information and meaning: Learning that the difficulty you are going through has a name, and that others have similar experiences, can be a relief. The feeling of "so I'm not strange after all" is one of the first steps towards change.
• Identification and distance: Following a character's experiences lets you look at your own life from a little further away. Seeing our own problems in someone else's story can help us see them more clearly.
• Finding words for feelings: Sentences in which a writer describes what you feel better than you could yourself can help you name your emotions.
• Structure and practice: Guidebooks offer the reader a concrete plan and steps that can be applied every day.
• Company in loneliness: When you cannot sleep at night, or feel you cannot talk to anyone, a book can be a quiet companion.

In Turkey, for many people a book is also a way of dealing with emotional distress without telling anyone. Someone worried about "what people will say if I see a psychologist" may wander for minutes along the self-help shelf of a bookshop. This is a valuable sign of a wish to seek help. A book can be the first stop for that wish; but it does not have to be the last. If what you read helps you, that is a good start; if the more you read, the more clearly you see how big the difficulty you are facing really is, that is also important information for thinking about the next step.

A good book offers the reader both a mirror and a window: it helps them see themselves and look out at the world.

What Does Research Say? The Evidence for Bibliotherapy

Most research on bibliotherapy focuses on self-help books based on cognitive behavioural therapy written for depression. Meta-analyses in this field (Cuijpers 1997; Gregory and colleagues 2004) reported an improvement in depressive symptoms ranging from moderate to large among people working with such books, compared with people on a waiting list.

These findings, however, need to be read correctly:

• The effects apply mainly to structured guidebooks based on cognitive behavioural therapy. The conclusion that "every book helps" or "reading novels cures depression" cannot be drawn from this research.
• The comparison was mostly with a waiting list; in other words, the benefit is relative to doing nothing. This does not mean a book is equivalent to face-to-face therapy.
• Participants in the studies were generally people with mild to moderate symptoms who were willing to read. The results cannot be generalised to people with severe depression, people who have difficulty concentrating, or people experiencing suicidal thoughts.
• Study numbers and scopes are not consistent across sources, which means the findings need to be interpreted with care.

Literary bibliotherapy, by contrast, has been studied less. Although there are promising observations about the contribution of reading novels or poetry to emotional expression, empathy or feelings of loneliness, there is not yet a strong and consistent evidence base. The effect of creative writing is a separate field of research; we discuss it in our article on writing therapy.

What Is Bibliotherapy, and What Is It Not? Its Limits and Risks

Knowing what bibliotherapy is not matters just as much as answering the question "what is bibliotherapy?".

Bibliotherapy does not replace therapy. A book cannot listen to you, adapt itself to your particular situation, or stop where you are struggling and think it through with you. When the difficulty you are experiencing deepens, it may be necessary to talk to a professional.

Not all self-help books are the same. Alongside guides with a scientific basis, the shelves also hold books with the message "just think positively and everything will be fine", books containing unsupported claims, and books that blame the reader. A book like this can leave someone already going through a hard time feeling that "I obviously don't want it enough".

The wrong book at the wrong time can be a burden. A novel that deals very harshly with death may not help someone who has recently suffered a heavy loss. For someone who has been through a traumatic experience, a book containing scenes similar to that experience may trigger distressing memories.

Reading can sometimes turn into avoidance. Constantly reading about a problem without taking any steps can be a way of postponing action under the name of "gathering information". Some people with anxiety may increase rather than reduce their anxiety by reading about their own symptoms for hours.

It should not be used for diagnosis. Recognising in yourself the symptoms you read about in a book does not mean you have that condition. A diagnosis can only be made through professional assessment.

How Can You Practise Bibliotherapy on Your Own?

If you would like to try bibliotherapy as a self-care tool, the following suggestions may guide you:

1. Set your aim. An intention such as "I want to sleep better", "I want to understand my anxiety" or "I want to make room to think about my loss" helps you choose the right book.
2. Question the source. When choosing a guidebook, look at the author's training in mental health, whether the book is based on scientific sources and whether it makes exaggerated promises. Treat titles such as "Free yourself from anxiety in seven days" with caution.
3. Read slowly. Rather than finishing a guide within a week, it may be more useful to read one chapter and practise the suggested exercise for a few days.
4. Take notes. Write down in a notebook the sentences you underline, the scenes that touch you and the questions that come to mind. When reading is combined with writing, it opens a deeper space for reflection.
5. Observe yourself. How do you feel after reading? Do you feel relieved, or more unsettled? If a book keeps weighing on you, do not hesitate to take a break.
6. Share. Joining a reading group or talking about what you read with someone you trust can turn reading from a solitary activity into an opportunity to connect. In many cities, municipal and public libraries run free reading groups.

Imagine a young person who has just finished university, is preparing for the KPSS (Turkey's public sector recruitment exam) and has barely left the house for months, buying a guidebook to understand their anxiety. They read a chapter every evening but never do the exercises; "I already know this," they say. A few weeks later they finish the book and notice that nothing has changed. What makes the difference here is not the book itself but how the reading is done. When the same young person actually starts practising a single exercise from one chapter, they may find that the book adds something for the first time. Or they may realise that the book is not enough on its own and that talking to a professional would be more appropriate; and that, too, is a valuable insight.

When Should You Seek Professional Support?

Books are a good starting point for many people. However, talking to a mental health professional is recommended in the following situations:

• If your symptoms have not eased within a few weeks despite the books you have read and the exercises you have practised
• If low mood, anxiety or restlessness is clearly affecting your work, school or relationships
• If you feel too tired or scattered to focus on reading, even on a single page
• If memories of a traumatic experience come to mind frequently and make daily life difficult
• If you are having thoughts of harming yourself or ending your life

If the last point applies, call 112 (emergency services) without delay or go to the nearest emergency department.

How Are Reading and Writing Used in Therapy?

In psychotherapy, reading often features as part of the work done between sessions. For example, during cognitive behavioural therapy, the client may be offered short informative texts on topics such as anxiety, depression or sleep. The text is then discussed together in the next session: Which part felt familiar? Which part seemed meaningless or difficult? Which exercise was tried?

In this use, the book works not as a substitute for therapy but as a tool that supports it. It helps reinforce what was discussed in the session, helps the person understand their own process better and helps them carry what they have learned into daily life. Literary texts, too, can at times become a means of expressing a feeling or making sense of an experience; when a client brings to the session a poem or paragraph that has touched them, that text can become the starting point of a conversation.

In individual therapy, a book is always suggested according to the person's needs, their reading habits and their energy at that time. For someone who does not enjoy reading, a short article, a podcast episode or just a single page of exercises may be more suitable than a book.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is bibliotherapy suitable for?

It can be supportive for people who enjoy reading, are experiencing mild or moderate difficulties and are willing to work on their own. It can also be used with children through picture books. When symptoms are severe, it is not enough on its own.

Does reading novels count as bibliotherapy?

Reading novels is an enjoyable and valuable activity, but not all novel reading is bibliotherapy. In literary bibliotherapy, the text is chosen with a purpose and what is read is reflected on or talked about.

Can self-help books replace therapy?

No. Although research shows that science-based guidebooks can be helpful for mild and moderate symptoms, a book cannot offer individual assessment and companionship. A book can be thought of as a tool that supports therapy or prepares the way for it.

How can I know which book I should read?

First identify your need, then look at the author's expertise, the book's scientific basis and how realistic its promises are. If you are in therapy, asking your therapist which book might suit you is also a good approach.

• #bibliotherapy
• #reading
• #self-help
• #reading and mental health

Yazar

Eda Erkan Alapala

Klinik Psikolog. İstanbul Kent Üniversitesi Klinik Psikoloji Tezli Yüksek Lisans mezunu; bilişsel davranışçı terapi, çocuk merkezli oyun terapisi ve çocuk-ergen psikoterapisi alanlarında eğitimlerini tamamlamıştır.

Eğitimler